
|
|
Using Modules to Teach General Chemistry
|
|
Instructional
Innovation Described
- What exactly is a "module," and what makes teaching with it
different from traditional teaching?
"Modules" are computer-based instructional units organized around a
question about a particular phenomenon that (a) students are expected
to have some prior understanding of, and (b) can provide a context
for introducing and understanding scientific concepts. For example,
one module developed through the ChemLinks Coalition
and the Modular Chemistry Consortium (MC2) is based upon a device nearly indispensable
to college students--the compact disc player--and asks whether, by
getting blue light from a solid, one could design a better CD player.
As the module description explains,
This module challenges students to think about a materials design
question, how to get light out of a solid, during two to three weeks
of their chemistry course. Light-emitting solids are essential for
many high-technology materials and products, including compact disc
(CD) players. Students make use of the periodic table to propose
color-specific emitting solids based on knowledge of periodic
properties, bonding, electronic transitions, solid structures and the
properties of light. (from MC2)
Thus, the "blue light" module, as it's known, provides a different
way of teaching periodicity and bonding as well as forms of
scientific reasoning: recognizing trends, making logical inferences
and deductions, and interpreting graphs.
Similarly, a module that uses automobile air bags to study gas laws
asks, "Can fast, gas-forming reactions save lives?" The following
description of the "air bag" module explains the areas of chemistry
and practical skills students will be expected to learn:
The development of airbag systems for automobiles will be used as a
case study for introducing a variety of chemicals and chemical
formulas, how to determine mass/mole relationships, and how to carry
out gas law computations. Other concepts such as heats of reaction
and kinetics will be introduced, but only to the extent necessary to
understand their importance in airbag design. Problem solving,
assessment of relative risks, and trade-offs in the design of airbag
systems will be explored. (from MC2)
However, using modules is more than just providing good, concrete
examples (like CD players and air bags) to explain chemical concepts.
Rather, modular instruction involves significant changes in both
curriculum (the content and organization of the course) and
pedagogy (the course's teaching- and learning-related
activities).
- How modules can change the traditional chemistry curriculum
Traditionally, the introductory chemistry curriculum has consisted of
breaking chemistry content knowledge into relatively discrete topics,
such as
stoichiometry,
a
periodicity,
b
gas laws, kinetics, and so forth. The curriculum consists of leading
students from topic to topic,
chapter to
chapter.c
However, because modules teach chemistry through understanding and
solving real-world problems, such as global warming or ensuring a
safe water supply, a module-based curriculum is not a march through
the standard chemistry topics. Instead, an introductory course may
include 3-5 modules, each of which "typically spans 3-4 weeks of
class time and utilizes a single real-world topic as a vehicle for
teaching a coherent set of chemistry concepts" (Gutwill-Wise, 2001). So, rather
than learning stoichiometry and mole equations when they come to
those chapters in the conventional curriculum, students learn about
those important concepts and skills through Session 6 of the global
warming module, titled "What Are Your Personal Contributions to
Greenhouse Gas Emissions? Moles and Stoichiometry." The goals for
this section are described here:
You will use laboratory investigations and stoichiometric
calculations to determine whether you personally are a significant
source of greenhouse gases. You will examine your daily activities to
estimate which have the greatest impacts on greenhouse gas levels.
For instance, are you responsible for more carbon dioxide emissions
if you drive to Boston or fly? Balancing equations, mole
calculations, stoichiometry, unit conversions, experimental design,
and order of magnitude are skills that will be developed during this
session. (Anthony, Brauch, &
Longley, 1998).
Thus, not only do students learn the skills and concepts associated
with calculating mole equations, but students also learn or use other
important skills such as scientific reasoning, problem solving and
troubleshooting experiments, marshaling evidence to support a claim,
and effective communication (oral, written) of methods and findings.
Modules lend themselves to fostering the kinds of knowledge, skills,
and attitudes that are expected of scientific literacy that is
characteristic of the kind of liberal arts education UST wishes to
offer its students.
- How modules can change teaching methods
Using modules necessitates not only curricular changes but changes in
conventional teaching methods. Traditionally, introductory chemistry
courses are taught in a lecture-lab format; students listen and take
notes during the instructor's lecture, then participate in a smaller
laboratory experience that allows students to practice using
equipment while conducting what are essentially verification
laboratories. However, to encourage the kind of intellectual
engagement that characterizes modular-based classes, instructors must
do more than lecture. Thus, instructors use teaching methods that
foster what is called active learning--which requires more
than just listening (e.g., writing, discussing, questioning), but
also engaging in higher-order cognitive activities such as
synthesis and
evaluation.d
A second major pedagogical feature of modular classrooms is
cooperative learning, which is defined by Roger T. Johnson and
David W. Johnson as "a relationship in a group of students that
requires positive interdependence (a sense of sink-or-swim together),
individual accountability (each of us has to contribute and learn),
interpersonal skills (communication, trust, leadership, decision
making, and conflict resolution), face-to-face promotive interaction,
and processing (reflecting on how well the team is functioning and
how to function even
better).e
A third feature of modules is inquiry-based laboratory
projects. Rather than doing traditional verification labs (that
is, following the steps of an experiment in order to achieve a
predetermined outcome), students work in teams to solve a problem and
are expected to use a combination of problem-solving skills,
subject-matter knowledge, and technical lab skills in a way that
resembles
actual scientific
research.f
- Modules and the UST Chemistry Department--"Getting Going"
From 1995 until 2001, Dr. Betsy Longley was an assistant professor of
chemistry at the University of St. Thomas. After arriving at UST with
a Ph.D. in
physical
chemistryg
from the University
of Pittsburgh, Betsy attempted to use modules to improve how the
majors in her Chem111 class learned chemistry.
Modules provided Betsy with the means to link her classroom with the
"real world," so to speak. Whether it was using a computer program to
adjust the chemical composition of an air bag to ensure it inflates
safely or using an "IR tutor" to demonstrate how molecular bonds bend
or stretch when absorbing infrared radiation, Betsy relied on
different types of technology to construct and deliver her modules;
instructional multimedia allowed her "to do or see something that is
otherwise impossible, dangerous, expensive, or too time-consuming"
(Anthony, Mernitz, et al.,
1998). And, according to Betsy, her students found that technology
enabled them to do two things much better: visualizing otherwise
abstract concepts, and manipulating chemical phenomena and
relationships. And from the institution's point of view, another
important outcome of Betsy's students' using modules was that they
were becoming more adept at using technology to solve problems and
present their findings.
Betsy's motivation for introducing this kind of technology into her
classroom stemmed from her concerns about traditional chemistry
education for non-majors, which are discussed below. Betsy used a
simple formula to drive her efforts: greater student engagement
equals greater student learning. Thus, because she believed she could
help students learn chemistry better if it is somehow connected to
their personal experience, she used modules to "real them in"--that
is, using real-life examples like automobile air bags, global
warming, compact-disc players, and dietary fats to reel students
in, drawing them into a deeper understanding and appreciation for
chemistry.
a.
Stoichiometry: The art or process of calculating the atomic
proportions, combining weights, and other numerical relations of
chemical elements and their compounds. Webster's Revised Unabridged
Dictionary, © 1996, 1998 MICRA, Inc.
b. Periodicity: The repetition of
similar properties in chemical elements, as indicated by their
positioning in the periodic table. Source: The American Heritage®
Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition.
c. For an example of a text taking
this kind of approach, see Leo J. Malone's Basic Concepts of
Chemistry (http://www.wiley.com/)
d. For definitions of active
learning, see http://trc.ucdavis.edu/trc/active/definiti.html. Bonwell
and Eison explain how active learning leads to greater learning:
"Use of these techniques in the classroom is
vital because of their powerful impact upon students' learning. For
example, several studies have shown that students prefer strategies
promoting active learning to traditional lectures. Other research
studies evaluating students' achievement have demonstrated that many
strategies promoting active learning are comparable to lectures in
promoting the mastery of content but superior to lectures in
promoting the development of students' skills in thinking and
writing. Further, some cognitive research has shown that a
significant number of individuals have learning styles best served by
pedagogical techniques other than lecturing. Therefore, a thoughtful
and scholarly approach to skillful teaching requires that faculty
become knowledgeable about the many ways strategies promoting active
learning have been successfully used across the disciplines. Further,
each faculty member should engage in self-reflection, exploring his
or her personal willingness to experiment with alternative approaches
to instruction." (http://www.ntlf.com/html/lib/bib/91-9dig.htm)
e. For more on cooperative learning,
see http://www.clcrc.com/
f. For more on inquiry-based
chemistry labs, see http://faculty.coloradomtn.edu/jeschofnig/inquiry.htm
g. Physical chemistry is that branch
of chemistry concerned with matters (no pun intended) of interest to
both physicists and chemists. According to a web site at the
University of Stuttgart, "the physico-chemist
describes and investigates the physical phenomena arising from
chemical processes. He [sic] tries to evaluate experimental data
using the methods of experimental and theoretical physics, to reveal
qualitative connections, to derive quantitative results on properties
and states of matter as on chemical reactions. In addition, those
results are applied to technical problems."
|